The best outdoor key safes in the UK for 2026, including police-preferred LPS 1175 models like the Supra C500 Pro, plus how to fit one and what your insurer may need.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you book a course or buy through them, Security Officers UK may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A key safe lets carers, family, cleaners or trades get into your home without you handing out spare keys. Fitted well, it’s a practical security tool. Fitted badly, or with a cheap uncertified box, it’s a gift to a burglar. This guide covers the best outdoor key safes in the UK for 2026, what “police preferred” really means and how to fit one securely.

Best key safes UK: quick comparison

Key safeBest forLock typeCertification (maker’s claim)
Supra C500 ProBest overallPush-button mechanicalLPS 1175 Issue 8 A5, Police Preferred Specification
Burton Keyguard XL / Digital XLMore keys or a digital keypadMechanical or digitalLPS 1175 Issue 8 A3, Police Preferred Specification
Master Lock 5401EURDBudget or low-risk useDial combinationNot independently certified to LPS 1175

Certification details are as published by the manufacturers and retailers in November 2026. Check the current LPCB listing if your insurer requires a specific rating.


1. Supra C500 Pro: Best Key Safe Overall

The Supra C500 Pro is the UK’s best-known police-preferred key safe and the one most often specified by councils, care providers and housing associations. The manufacturer states that it is tested to LPCB LPS 1175 Issue 8 rating A5 and meets the Secured by Design Police Preferred Specification.

It uses a push-button mechanical lock, so there are no batteries to fail, and a shutter cover protects the buttons from weather and prying eyes. It holds several standard house keys. Fitted to solid masonry with the supplied fixings, it’s the default choice for most homes.

Good for: carers’ access, elderly relatives, holiday lets. Watch out for: older non-Pro C500 stock with a lower rating, so make sure the listing says “Pro”.

View the Supra C500 Pro on Amazon →


2. Burton Keyguard XL: Best for More Keys or a Digital Keypad

Burton’s Keyguard XL range is a strong alternative with a larger body that suits households needing several key sets or fobs. Burton states that it meets LPS 1175 Issue 8 rating A3 and the Police Preferred Specification. A digital keypad version (Keyguard Digital XL) lets you change codes quickly, which helps when carers or tenants change often.

Good for: larger households, landlords, frequent code changes. Watch out for: battery checks on the digital version.

View the Burton Keyguard XL on Amazon →


3. Master Lock 5401EURD: Best Budget Key Safe

The Master Lock 5401EURD is a popular, low-cost wall-mounted key safe with a dial combination and a weather cover. It’s fine for low-risk uses such as a garage or outbuilding key, or as a temporary solution. It isn’t independently certified to LPS 1175, so we wouldn’t rely on it for your front door key if your insurer has requirements, and it’s not the one to choose for carers’ access to a vulnerable person’s home.

View the Master Lock 5401EURD on Amazon →


What to look for in a key safe

Independent certification

Look for LPCB LPS 1175 certification and the Secured by Design Police Preferred Specification. These mean the safe has been attack-tested by an independent body. A high price or “heavy duty” label isn’t proof of security.

Mechanical or digital

Mechanical push-button safes need no power and work in any weather. Digital keypads make code changes easy but need battery checks. For most homes, mechanical is the simplest, most reliable choice.

Capacity

Count the keys and fobs you need to store, then add one. Overstuffing a small key safe makes it hard to close properly.

How to fit a key safe securely

  • Fix it to solid brick or concrete with the supplied security fixings, never to render, cladding, timber or a fence.
  • Place it out of sight from the street, ideally around a corner or behind a gate, but not right beside the door it opens.
  • Change the code from the factory setting, and change it again whenever someone who knows it no longer needs access.
  • Scramble the buttons or dial after closing, so the code isn’t left showing.
  • Never label the key with your address.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are key safes safe?

A certified, police-preferred key safe that’s fixed to solid masonry, out of sight, with a code you change regularly is a reasonably safe way to share access. Cheap, uncertified boxes fixed with weak screws can be prised off quickly.

Will a key safe affect my home insurance?

It can. Some insurers accept key safes only if they’re police preferred or LPS 1175 certified, and some won’t pay out if a key safe was used to gain entry without force. Check your policy wording or ask your insurer before fitting one.

What does police preferred mean?

“Police Preferred Specification” is the Secured by Design standard, run by Police Crime Prevention Initiatives. Products that carry it have passed independent security testing, such as LPCB’s LPS 1175 for key safes.

Can I fit a key safe myself?

Yes, if you’re comfortable drilling into masonry. Use the supplied fixings and follow the manufacturer’s instructions; the fixing is as important as the safe itself. Renters should ask their landlord first.

More home security guides: best smart locks · best home safes · best security lights. Or browse every guide in our home security hub.